Quote from: MysteryFan89 on September 17, 2023, 10:05:29 PMYeah, I don't like the early Tom Swift series. I do love what you've done with the characters. Female Joe really works.Thanks so much. If you knew how much I second-guessed that change after I made it, you would know how much I appreciate that you approve of the change. I know not everyone will feel the same, but it helps to have you on my side!
I rarely say that about people (fanfic writers) that change the gender of a TV or book character.
Quote from: Brentski on September 17, 2023, 01:21:47 AMNo, I'm not referring to the 60s versions. The originals I'm speaking of are the 1927 versions that entered the public domain this year. The named characters are the same, as are the setting. I've used those elements to build my story. You can get the 1927 texts for the first three books at Project Gutenberg. The details of the stories and some of the characterizations differ from the later, revised versions of the stories. There are also 25 chapters in each book instead of 20 - which gives a bit more room for character dialog and added plot elements.
I've read a few Nancy Drew's and enjoyed them. I should give Tom Swift a try!
Quote from: Brentski on September 17, 2023, 01:21:47 AMNo, I'm not referring to the 60s versions. The originals I'm speaking of are the 1927 versions that entered the public domain this year. The named characters are the same, as are the setting. I've used those elements to build my story. You can get the 1927 texts for the first three books at Project Gutenberg. The details of the stories and some of the characterizations differ from the later, revised versions of the stories. There are also 25 chapters in each book instead of 20 - which gives a bit more room for character dialog and added plot elements.
I've read a few Nancy Drew's and enjoyed them. I should give Tom Swift a try!
Quote from: MysteryFan89 on September 16, 2023, 04:27:26 PMWhen you say original, do you mean the 1960 version of the books? Those are awesome. I'm also a fan of Nancy Drew, and Tom Swift.
Quote from: Brentski on September 16, 2023, 03:35:12 PMThanks a bunch for the sub! The book is wholesome, but I did add a kiss or two between Frank & Callie in one chapter. That's as far as I ever plan to go in that direction. There is no cursing, and no violence that wasn't in the originals.
Is this fanfiction? I'm going to say 'no'. The Hardy books (first three of the original text) are in the public domain and available for legal use in new stories. These stories can be copyrighted, and I've applied for the copyright on my book. The copyright excluded the PD elements of the old characters and setting, but my story and any new characters are under copyright. Anyway, my main point is that being able to take out a copyright is, to me, the line the divides fan fiction from uh, not fan fiction.
I've written my fair share of fan-fic, and some of it was pretty okay (to pat myself on the back), but I can't legally publish it or claim copyright. This book is different.
Quote from: MysteryFan89 on September 16, 2023, 12:33:02 PMI've subscribed to you. Can't wait to read it, I love wholesome take on on my favourite book series. Would this be considered fanfiction?
Quote from: Brentski on September 16, 2023, 10:26:00 AMThanks! I've been worried how people would react to that change.
That's part of the topic for next weeks article on my Substack. (https://bayportmysteries.substack.com/ shameless plug)
The real truth is that the idea grabbed me by the throat and wouldn't let go. I thought up other good reasons - such as differentiating Frank & Joe a bit more, and better reflecting boys and girls roles in modern society. But those came after the inspiration made up my mind.
Quote from: MysteryFan89 on September 16, 2023, 09:26:21 AMLove your change for Joe. What made you change the character?